Arizona Seeks to Privatize its Prisons
Published October 24, 2009 @ 12:56PM PT

Arizona officials are planning to seek bids to privatize the state's entire prison system, handing over the keys to nine of the state's 10 prisons -- including death row -- to private company like the Corrections Corporation of America. If this doesn't sound like bad enough idea, a 'savings-sharing' scheme behind the plan makes it even worse.
This plan has been circulating in Arizona for some time, but I haven't covered it here until now, because I didn't want to sound the alarm for something I thought seemed too insane to ever actually happen. But a front-page story in today's New York Times forced me to pay a bit more attention. (Thanks to reader and activist Camille Tilley for keeping me in the loop as this issue developed over the last few months).
Let's count the reasons this is a bad idea:
- Private prisons, motivated by profit to keep costs at a bare minimum, are terrible at providing prisoner services. Most state prisons are poorly run and underfunded, but private prisons are designed to be coldly efficient, lowest-common-denominator incarceration factories.
- Safety is compromised at private prisons, which are often crowded and run with fewer security guards, many of whom are barely trained.
- Arizona is asking a company to pay $100 million up front for the privilege of running state prisons, and the state and the company will then split any savings delivered by the company. This savings-sharing seems dangerous, because the company will have to cut costs twice as deeply to bring home a profit it likes.
- Studies have shown that private prisons don't actually save the state money in the end -- they just make profit for shareholders. One hedge fund manager recommended private prison stocks just this week.
- Death row has never been managed for profit in this country, and most private prison operators don't have expertise in running maximum-security facilities. It's a catastrophe waiting to happen.
I was a little disappointed as well to see that today's Times story misses one of the biggest arguments against this plan. The state rationalizes the plan because it will save them money in a crunch. Other states are also saving money on corrections, in a more humane and reasonable way: by releasing people who are eligible for parole, by diverting drug offenders to treatment and by releasing non-violent elderly prisoners a few months early. This argument wasn't raised in today's story, but maybe that's because it's such a longshot in the tough-on-crime Arizona desert that Joe Arpaio calls home.
Arizona lawmakers should think again before making this disastrous and short-sighted play. There are ways to save a few bucks without selling your prisons, and this privatization will be bad for prisoners, guards and taxpayers. Only the corporations will win.
The Times story is here, and the Business of Detention website is a great resource on private prison operators and issues.
Share this Post
Related Posts
Comments (21)
Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.
Facebook
Twitter
Digg
StumbleUpon
Delicious
Email




















"Not to mention that the business is "like a hotel where you lock in the guests, and if they try to escape you shoot them."
Shades of "Hotel California" have come to fruition in America. Sure, its a bad idea Matt...unfortunately until some event like Attica comes to haunt the company, they will continue to roll out these "lowest-common-denominator incarceration factories."
Posted by mark schmanke on 10/24/2009 @ 04:17PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
We must end the for profit jail industrial complex just like the war complex, health care, pharmaceutical, bank, oil, auto they are all to strong and exert too much pressure to control us. We have more people, by far, in jail than any other country. The reason behind this fact is pure greed. Judges have been charged with accepting bribes in the millions to ensure enough people go to jail with longer sentences. They want to keep every cell full it is the way the make money. Just like the people that profit from war they strive to keep us in war at all times this is the way they make money.
Posted by Cherokee Fred Jesus on 10/25/2009 @ 04:38AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
These jail are not the hotels you have been led to believe. Some lock down prisoners 23 hours a day. It is not a good thing to have your freedom taken away. This punishment .should be reserved for crimes against other humans. Yet our for profit jail system has more locked up than any other country. Many for victemless non-violent crimes, kinda like our war machine invading a country for no legitimate reason.
Posted by Cherokee Fred Jesus on 10/25/2009 @ 04:44AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Matt, Thank you for writing on this serious issue in Arizona and creating public awareness. The legislators need to accept the responsibility for the laws they created that have created the chaos, overcrowding and inhumane conditions of confinement in our jails, prisons and detention centers. Washing their hands of their responsibility in all this is unacceptable and cowardly. Follow the money.... says it all.
Posted by Camille Tilley on 10/25/2009 @ 08:35AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Well said Camille, and thanks to Matt on an excellent article.
I think the judges, prosecutors, & others - that are involved in sending people to prison - should be required to go and see (first-hand) the conditions of the prisons where they're sending people.
Sort of like the old "Scared Straight" documentary, that sent kids/teens to see the conditions in prisons as a deterent.
But instead of sending kids, this would involve the persons who are going to have a hand in sending people to those prisons. MAYBE, just maybe it would make people think twice before
And there should be some sort of effort to make these "random visits" (to the extent possible), to avoid the potential problems like those in the recent "Hiding ‘Problem Prisoners’ to Pass Inspection" article.
Posted by Bryan Snowden on 10/26/2009 @ 02:39AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Bryan, I couldn't agree with you more. I've said the same thing myself many times. For more on the subject of the effects of incarceration, read Dr. Zimbardo's "Stanford Prison Project" and his book, "The Lucifer Effect". Just as doctors have to intern as part of their training, those building the mass industrial prison complex America has become, also need to intern to gain real life experience by living in conditions of confinement where they send people to be housed in the jails and prisons of our nation. This would include, first of all, those who create the laws to gain "the vote" - the Legislators and Congressmen/women, followed by the lawyers who get "rich" in all this, the prosecutors with "win-at-all cost" mentality-casting fair justice and balance aside; the judges who answer to the prosecutors and came to the bench from winning "high-profile" cases as lawyers; probation officers with life-time registries for offenders and ongoing residuals; corporate officials/salespeople profiting off human misery. If these people could put themselves in the position of a falsely accused defendant and sit in the county jails and prisons, only then would we see reform.
In Maricopa County, Arizona read the real life stories of a broken and corrupt system that is Hell-bent on destroying lives for political and financial gain. Ask yourself, why the Legislators and Governor Brewer would propose and sign a bill to sell/privatize all the state prisons (existing)?
Read the following:
"Jingle Jangle" by Jim Rix, the Ray Krone story of a man falsely accused, wrongfully convicted and imprisoned (Death Row). Prosecutors, decades later still working in the Maricopa County Attorney's office.
"Accidental Felons" by Daniel Horne, a successful corporate executive and family man. His choice in Arizona, a state with harsh mandatory minimum sentencing where on a first offense, a person is facing 10 years in prison or a plea bargain, where common sense is tossed and Mr. Horne had no choice but to take one year in Sheriff Arpaio's county jail and the label of "violent felon". Where is fair justice in this? What happened to the DUI label in all this? There was no malicious intent in this car accident.
Who are all the profiteers in the criminal justice system and the mass industrial prison complex? "Follow the money" to find the answers, as people are living in a war within our own nation being terrorized themselves, as lives, families and our nation's future are being destroyed with draconian policies, laws and the loss of individual's rights. This is especially true in Maricopa County, Arizona which can be read about daily in the media. What is happening in Arizona will spread nationwide. Public awareness and action is needed by all.
This is the tip of the iceberg of a decaying county, state and nation. People need to wake-up, they are not immune from the destruction to others and in fact are paying the price. People are also at risk for a felonies which throw them into the criminal justice system, a place we never knew existed in America.
This is the largest scale manipulation of the people in the "land of the free" that should send chills up every person's spine.
Posted by Camille Tilley on 10/26/2009 @ 10:50AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
*oops, the spell checker went wonky on me for some reason, and the page decided to post my comment before it was done*
The 4th paragraph should read: "before sending people to jail and/or prisons - without knowing EXACTLY what they're really doing to these people."
Posted by Bryan Snowden on 10/26/2009 @ 02:46AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
I say set the captive free and monitor them on probation! about five years each, that's a college education....but hey I'm with stupid by force and delay...lol
Posted by Jacqueline Bowen on 10/26/2009 @ 07:46AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
To understand the Arizona criminal justice system, which is broken and a failed system people need to get informed. Start by reading books that explain what people face when they move to Arizona. Attracted by the "new" construction, architecture, beautiful geography, job opportunities, and what appears to be thinking ahead. The sad truth is people have been deceived by the tourist bureau, Chamber of Commerce, real estate and national builder brochures -- it is a back-water state that takes people back to the 50's and Jim Crow era. Unless the people of Arizona wake up, they are doomed to continue on the path that the elected officials created for their own personal agendas, investments and pensions. Meanwhile innocent people are seeing their lifetime earnings destroyed, their lives destroyed, their children's lives destroyed and the society's future. It is a decaying state unless some strong leadership steps forward for change. So far the state lacks strong leadership except for bigotry, intolerance and hatred.
Posted by Camille Tilley on 10/26/2009 @ 06:47PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
"Jingle Jangle" the Ray Krone story, innocent man spent 17 years in prison Maricopa County, AZhttp://www.jinglejangle.us/
"Accidental Felons" DUI's and mandatory minimum sentencing in Arizonahttp://danielhorne.blogspot.com/
Prosecutorial Misconduct: Will there be accountability?http://danielhorne.blogspot.com/2009/08/prosecutor-misconduct-will-there-be.html
Posted by camille tilley on 11/07/2009 @ 07:23AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
After speaking to one of my legislators last night, I realized he thinks he is holding integrity. The prejudice against these people is growing so strong that he actually told me that I was getting manipulated by the prisoners because I was a nice person.
No Senator Geddes, I am an activist that knows abuse when I see it on a vulnerable population.
Posted by darcy lagana on 10/27/2009 @ 08:47AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Dang...
That's scary, all these politicians that seem to believe the nonsense they spew on these kinda issues.
Maybe its just a "put-on" to snag the "tough on crime" label for their political careers - that's been a "win-win" stance for, oh... IDK? something like, 40+ years - in recent history.
On second thought, I'm not sure which prospect is actually scarier - the former or the later.
Posted by Bryan Snowden on 10/27/2009 @ 07:18PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Business of Detention -- as the "Prison State" continue to grow, while education and tourism decline, who would want to vacation in a prison state with harsh mandatory minimum sentencing? Incarceration and Prison Privatization is s transfer from manufacturing to incarceration. Where human beings become a "commodity" known as "head-counts", "bed counts" to fill prison beds. How sick and depraved is this?
http://www.businessofdetention.com/
detention, enforcement, policy »Second immigration official leaves new federal office[ 24 Oct 2009 | No Comment |
The Center for Investigative Reporting report that:A second high-ranking official in a two-month-old federal office that oversees immigration detention policy and planning has left the government, sources say.Cree Zischke, tasked with addressing detainee health care issues for Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Office of Detention Policy and Planning, departed just weeks after her boss, Dr. Dora Schriro,(former Director of Arizona Department of Corrections) left ICE in late September to become commissioner of New York City’s jails.“I am no longer with the ICE Office of Detention Planning and Policy (sic),” she wrote in an out-of-office auto-reply received on …
ICE Promises Detention Reforms, CCA Announces New Detention Center[ 7 Oct 2009 | One Comment | ]
On the same day that Corrections Corporation of America opened a new 500-bed immigrant detention center in Georgia, Homeland Security officials released a highly anticipated review of detention centers. Accompanied by recommendations and next steps, the review promises better federal oversight and health care in the largely outsourced network of prisons and jails that house a daily average of 32,000 people with pending immigration and refugee status requests.“The government has recognized that it has a massive system with serious problems, and has identified steps to ameliorate the situation,” …
Camille Tilley
NCCJR National Coalition of Criminal Justice Reform
Posted by Camille Tilley on 11/02/2009 @ 11:38AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
The Word - Jail Sweet Jail | May 15,2008 - Andrei Cherny | ColbertNation.com
Source: www.colbertnation.comColbertNation.com video - If you have an extra bedroom, you could be the proud owner/operator of a charming private prison.
Posted by Camille Tilley on 11/06/2009 @ 08:01PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Arizona culture of abuse of power....
http://www.kpho.com/news/21470567/detail.html
Posted by Camille Tilley on 11/02/2009 @ 12:47PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Where prisons profit the most is not from the inmates but from the families of the inmates. If the inmate receive money from family they have to pay for all their necessities, shampoo, soap etc. The prisoner has to go 60 days without money or necessities to be considered indigent and to get these items for free. For each infraction the prisoner is fined, from the funds the family sends; they make a killing off the canteen and the phones again these are things the families pay for. If Arizona goes forward with this plan, I would suggest organizing a strike by the family members and then we'll see how much profit the shareholders get.
Posted by Cynthia LoMonaco on 11/04/2009 @ 03:39PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
If they want to cut costs, perhaps they should stop putting people in prison for non-violent "crimes" and provide treatment programs for people using dangerous drugs instead of catering to prison guard unions and the "lock em' up" mentality.
Posted by Jason Martin on 11/04/2009 @ 08:47PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
this is a very scary thought to have privately owned and run prisons. they will just bribe the judges to send more people to prison therefore no one will get a real or fair trial. bad idea for america, bad idea for arizona.
Posted by jeff zander on 11/05/2009 @ 07:02AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
Abolish Private "for profit" Prisons A “SINGLE VOICE PROJECT” is the official name of the petition sponsored by: The National Public Service Council To Abolish Private Prisons (NPSCTAPP)
THIS PETITION SEEKS TO ABOLISH ALL PRIVATE PRISONS IN THE UNITED STATES, (or any place subject to its jurisdiction) The National Public Service Council To Abolish Private Prisons (NPSCTAPP) is a grass roots organization driven by a single objective. We want the United States government to reclaim sole authority for state and federal prisons on US soil. We want the United States Congress to immediately rescind all state and federal contracts that permit private prisons “for profit” to exist in the United States, or any place subject to its jurisdiction. We understand that the problems that currently plague our government, its criminal justice system and in particular, the state & federal bureau of prisons (and most correctional and rehabilitation facilities) are massive. However, it is our solemn belief that the solutions for prison reform will remain unattainable and virtually impossible as long as private prisons for profit are permitted to operate in America. Prior to the past month, and the fiasco of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, AIG, Lehman Brothers, and now the “Big Three” American Automobile manufacturers, the NPSCTAPP has always felt compelled to highlight the “moral Bottom line” when it comes to corrections and privatization. Although, we remain confounded by the reality that our government has allowed our justice system to be operated by private interests. The NPSCTAPP philosophy has always been “justice” should not be for sale at any price. It is our belief that the inherent and most fundamental responsibility of the criminal justice system should not be shirked, or “jobbed-out.”
This is not the same as privatizing the post office or some trash pick up service in the community. There has to be a loss of meaning and purpose when an inmate looks at a guard’s uniform and instead of seeing an emblem that reads State Department of Corrections or Federal Bureau of Prisons, he sees one that says: “Atlas Prison Corporation.” Let’s assume that the real danger of privatization is not some innate inhumanity on the part of its practitioners but rather the added financial incentives that reward inhumanity. The same logic that motivates companies to operate prisons more efficiently also encourages them to cut corners at the expense of workers, prisoners and the public. Every penny they do not spend on food, medical care or training for guards is a dime they can pocket. What happens when the pennies pocketed are not enough for the shareholders? Who will bailout the private prison industry when they hold the government and the American people hostage with the threat of financial failure…“bankruptcy?” What was unimaginable a month ago merits serious consideration today. State and Federal prison programs originate from government design, and therefore, need to be maintained by the government. It’s time to restore the principles and the vacated promise of our judicial system. John F. Kennedy said, “The time to repair the roof is while the sun is shinning”. Well the sun may not be shinning but, it’s not a bad time to begin repair on a dangerous roof that is certain to fall…. because, “Incarcerating people for profit is, in a word WRONG” There is an urgent need for the good people of this country to emerge from the shadows of cynicism, indifference, apathy and those other dark places that we migrate to when we are overwhelmed by frustration and the loss of hope.
It is our hope that you will support the NPSCTAPP with a show of solidarity by signing our petition. We intend to assemble a collection of one million signatures, which will subsequently be attached to a proposition for consideration. This proposition will be presented to both, the Speaker Of The House Of Representatives (Nancy Pelosi) and the United States Congress. Please Help Us. We Need Your Support. Help Us Spread The Word About This Monumental And Courageous Challenge To Create Positive Change. Place The Link To The Petition On Your Website! Pass It On! The SINGLE VOICE PETITION and the effort to abolish private “for profit” prisons is the sole intent of NPSCTAPP. Our project does not contain any additional agendas. We have no solutions or suggestions regarding prison reform. However, we are unyielding in our belief that the answers to the many problems which currently plague this nation’s criminal justice system and its penal system in particular, cannot and will not be found within or assisted by the private “for profit” prison business. The private “for profit” prison business has a stranglehold on our criminal justice system. Its vice-like grip continues to choke the possibility of justice, fairness, and responsibility from both state and federal systems. These new slave plantations are not the answer! For more information please visit: http://www.npsctapp.blogsppot.com or email: williamthomas@exconciliation.com To sign the petition please visit: http://www.petitiononline.com/gufree2/petition.html
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT! William Thomas National Community Outreach Facilitator The National Public Service Council To Abolish Private Prisons P.O. Box 156423 San Francisco, California 94115 reply
Posted by camille tilley on 11/15/2009 @ 10:53AM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
http://www.authorhouse.com/BookStore/ItemDetail.aspx?bookid=22009
A true story of corruption, politics and for-profit private prisons
This must read book into prison privatization is the firsthand account of the uncovering of corruption leading to the largest civil penalty at that time by the Florida Commission on, the discrediting of the academic “guru” and Wall Street darling of prison privatization, the resignation of the executive director of the state agency that oversees the private prisons, and the authors thrust into the position as a leader in the fight against the private prison industry.
Ken Kopczynski describes in detail, backed up with copious documentation, how he unraveled the financial dealings of Dr. Charles Thomas and his relationship with the private prison industry. Follow Kopczynski as he pieces clues together exposing how the private prison industry came into being and how they used Thomas and C. Mark Hodges, Executive Director of the Florida Correctional Privatization Commission, to promote the industry.
"If this book were only about individuals whose greed led them to run
afoul of ethics rules and who were hoisted on their own petard, it would
be interesting but not nearly as important as it is. What makes this
cautionary tale that deserves to be better known is the way Kopczynski
reveals patterns in the way that for-profit prison vendors do business."
Correctional Law Reporter, April/May 200
Posted by camille tilley on 11/15/2009 @ 04:17PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.
http://allthemoneyouneed.com/2009/05/prison-profiteers-who-makes-money-from-mass-incarceration/
Prison Profiteers Who Makes Money from Mass Incarceration
Prison Profiteers Who Makes Money from Mass Incarceration
The astonishing range of industries, corporations, and individuals
profiting from the imprisonment of over 2.3 million Americans.
“Positive: With the baby boomlet demographics, we foresee increasing demand for juvenile [incarceration] services. Negative:…it is often difficult to maintain the occupancy rates required for profitability.”—from a report produced for the private prison industry by investment analysts First Analysis Securities CorporationLocking up 2.3 million people isn’t cheap. Each year federal, state, and local governments spend over $185 billion annually in tax dollars to ensure that one out of every 137 Americans is imprisoned. Prison Profiteers looks at the private prison companies, investment banks, churches, guard unions, medical corporations, and other industries and individuals that benefit from this country’s experiment with mass imprisonment. It lets us follow the money from public to private hands and exposes how monies formerly designated for the public good are diverted to prisons and their maintenance. Find out where your tax dollars are going as you help to bankroll the biggest prison machine the world has ever seen.Contributors include: Judy Greene on private prison giants Geo (formerly Wackenhut) and CCA; Anne-Marie Cusac on who sells electronic weapons to prison guards; David Lapido on how private corporations profit from prison labor; Wil S. Hylton on the largest prison health care provider; Ian Urbina on how prison labor supports the military; Kirsten Levingston on the privatization of public defense; Jennifer Gonnerman on the costs to neighborhoods from which prisoners are removed; Kevin Pranis on the banks and brokerage houses that finance prison building; and Silja Talvi on the American Correctional Association as a tax-funded lobbyist for professional prison bureaucracies.
Posted by camille tilley on 11/15/2009 @ 07:23PM PT
You must be signed in to report content.